Shopping Cart

Your shopping cart is empty
Visit the shop

#157 What’s the difference?

This may be the most important article I ever write, considering that it deals with the difference between “The Tailwheel Town Way” and “The Acme Way”.

I believe that at least 90 % of all flight training is done the “Acme” way.  In fact, it’s probably true that  almost all flight schools are “Acme”.  Occasionally, you’ll find an individual flight instructor who is not, but you’ll rarely find an entire school that is not Acme.

I’ve long derided the “Acme” way of flight instruction.  I’ve always claimed that “Acme” flight instruction techniques are vastly inferior to Tailwheel Town methods.  It’s only fair for me to say why we differ.

It has to do with fundamentals.  Acme tends to ignore fundamentals in favor of instrument training and hi tech panels. The Acme grad may be a flier who can make an instrument approach but is incapable of a coordinated turn and may end up spinning in for lack of knowledge and proper reflexes.

You will probably not find a teacher of flying who is under fifty years old if you search for a non-Acme flight instructor.  Virtually EVERYONE is aware of this situation.  It’s kinda like the situation of the Whuffo who buys a house next to an airport and then proceeds to complain about the airplane noise.  We all know about the situation, but we continue to fuss about it.  Flight training is similar.  It’s one of the few pursuits where most teachers are far less experienced than most who make a living flying.  That’s because only Acme will hire instructors with relatively low time.  It’s also the reason that so many student pilots are abandoned by their teacher.  Most flight instructors are building time while they lust after that airline job.  When it is finally in their grasp, they haul ass, leaving all their students to find another flight instructor, who is also lusting after that airline job!  Older guys who have been around, whether or not they ever flew for the airlines, will sometimes turn to flight instruction, mainly because they can’t stand to see the process being botched.  And, although women tend to be in the minority, they too tend to be older and more experienced if they are non-Acme.  Amelia Reid comes to mind, along with Edna Gardner Whyte and quite a few others.

A.  The understanding of basic aerodynamics and energy management.  Acme tends to rely on  “integrated instruction”.  That implies a dependence on instruments.  I’d just as soon throw a blanket over the whole instrument panel for those starting out.  Does Acme deal with adverse yaw and ever cover the turn coordinator?  Probably not. They never deal with “G” force and they all think that a standing start with brakes set (and lots of runway foolishly left behind them) results in a “Short Field” takeoff.   So much for an understanding of basic aerodynamics and energy management.

B.  The control of the airplane when in proximity to the ground.  Acme

Amal 003

Amal Ajmi blasts around the irrigation pivot in Jay Haldeman’s J-5. (photo by Debbie Volle)

encourages fear of proximity with mother earth.  I can’t tell you how many Acme trained pilots, when in the Tailwheel Town airplane have expressed a fear of hitting terrain that was a mile away.  Our use of an irrigation pivot in order to familiarize a flyer with terrain flying is something that Acme would never do.

C.  The pattern.  Acme uses a huge pattern and Tailwheel Town uses a tiny one.  Not only does that radically increase the number of takeoffs and landings per hour that the Tailwheel Town flyer gets to do, it also increases their confidence through practice of “whipping it up”, so that it’s not necessary to make a long, drawn out approach in order to have a decent landing.  I believe that if you ever hear, “The key to a good landing is a good approach,” you should run, screaming.

D.  Emergency techniques.  Did you ever hear of those things that you can’t prove, but that you just are SURE are correct?  Well, this might be one of them.  I think that Acme instills much more confidence in engines than

DSCN4617

Inside every airplane there beats the heart of a glider, each with a different level of performance. At 7,000 MSL over Central Oregon with the prop stopped.

 

we do at Tailwheel Town.  That’s just one reason that every Tailwheeler gets to do at least one Dead Stick landing.  Most Acme flyers don’t even know what that means!  I had one Acme flyer claim that most of their landings were Dead Stick.  That flyer thought that “Dead Stick” meant closed throttle.  I had to explain that it means engine off with propeller STOPPED.

E.  Acme rarely spins.  Acme flyers rarely receive any spin training or practice, so they remain fearful of cross controlled maneuvers and can hardly remain coordinated.

That’s just a partial list.  It hits the high points but I believe it discloses the basic differences between Acme and Tailwheel Town.  Tailwheel Town tends to focus on fundamentals.  Acme tries to make its students airline pilots.  Personally, I think that’s skipping a tremendously important stage in flight training.  Acme wants to fill the heads of its students with knowledge of instrument flying, Crew Resource Management and generally how to think.  Tailwheel Town assumes that we all know how to think and that fundamentals of aviation come first, followed by all those other sides of aviation, with which Acme begins.

Having ranted against Acme for a long time, let me repeat what one of my early mentors taught me.  Student pilots often need altitudes, power settings and other conditions to “hang their hat on.  Acme does that.  They give their students speeds, RPMs, flap settings, etc. to give them a structure upon which to build their skills.  That’s often necessary but, like a pacifier in a toddler’s mouth, should be abandoned eventually.  At Tailwheel Town, the answer to many questions is “It all depends”.  That may be a bit vague for some flyers, but it is true.

But of course, that’s just my opinion.  Since I’ve recently decided not to try to change the world of Flight Training, it’s doubtful that many will be exposed to my opinion, let alone adopt it.

Happy Swooping.

Brian

6 comments to #157 What’s the difference?

  • Robey

    As a member of the Twin Cities Chapter of Tailwheel Town Fan Club, and graduate of the Tailwheel Town School of Aviation Heresy correspondence course (with honors!) I’m here spreading the “word” and to let you know I’ve introduced two Citabria CFIs to power off 180s to wheel landings. Neither had ever tried it, they both loved it, said it was a hoot. Perhaps they’ll add it to their instructional repertoire (that’s French for bag of tricks).

  • I specialize in tailwheel instruction and I have done my best to separate myself from industrialized flight training. All of my instruction save for my instrument and multi training was very grassroots. I keep my students’ heads outside of the airplane as much as possible. I cover instruments and teach one-wheel landings. I’m 33 and have no airline ambitions. I don’t shut off engines with students (I’ve done it on my own, but never to a landing) and I’ve been known to say the adage about good landings and approaches. Does that make me Acme or tailwheel? Or just an anomaly?

    I’d really like to take your advanced course sometime as I know that there’s still a lot I can learn in this business.

    • brian

      As Ryan knows, we are all students. I think that the day we stop being students is the day we might as well hang up our helmets and goggles and ground ourselves. As far as Dead Sticking, we all have our thoughts about it and the reasons we either do or don’t do it. Like many things, I’ve worked my way into it slowly, but now have over a hundred of them and only one re-start (early on). What does it make you? Seems to me that it simply makes you… you! And that’s probably a good thing. I’ve heard a lot about Ryan. All good. You’re not Acme. I’d love to fly with you.

  • I absolutely agree. I own a C140 and do tailwheel instruction in Reno, NV. I agree with you that most pilots stick and rudder skills are sub par. Just for the record, I don’t instruct the Acme way either and I’m 45 years old. So there are still a few of us around…….

    • brian

      Josh, thank gawd there are still a few of us, including you, around! Delighted that you wrote. Keep up the good work… perhaps I should say, “keep the faith”. Thank you!

Leave a Reply

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>